2012 PV Module Guide: Page 4 of 4

Intermediate

Inside this Article

Choosing Solar-Electric Modules
Comparative Module Size
Module size is creeping up, with both pros and cons: A 96-cell, 410 W Grape Solar module (left) is almost 6.5 feet tall and more than 27.5 square feet, compared to a more common 72-cell, 230 W module (right) at about 17.5 square feet.
SunPower Solar-Electric Module
SunPower’s 318-watt module offers 19.5% efficiency—top of the industry, but at a premium price.
Sanyo Solar-Electric Module
Sanyo’s HIT series offers a +10% (no minus) power tolerance.
Day4 Solar-Electric Module
Day4 Energy is one of four manufacturers that have modules rated at a low NOCT of 43°C.
Sun Earth Solar-Electric Module
Sun Earth Solar Power (Nbsolar) represents one of the three manufacturers that have modules with a PTC-to-STC ratio of 0.92 or better.
Silicon Energy Solar-Electric Array
Silicon Energy’s power warranty is 15 years at 90% of rated output, and 30 years at 80%.
SolarWorld Solar-Electric Module
SolarWorld and other companies offer linear warranties that allow a yearly percentage decrease in output over the warranty period.
Choosing Solar-Electric Modules
Comparative Module Size
SunPower Solar-Electric Module
Sanyo Solar-Electric Module
Day4 Solar-Electric Module
Sun Earth Solar-Electric Module
Silicon Energy Solar-Electric Array
SolarWorld Solar-Electric Module

Warranty

Every PV module carries two distinct types of warranty—a materials (or workmanship) warranty and a power warranty. 

The materials warranty covers the module’s parts and workmanship. It is critical to read the fine print, but a materials/workmanship guarantee generally provides service or replacement of defective modules by the manufacturer. Some of the limitations are based on the parts that module manufacturers use to assemble modules, such as quick-connects and sealed junction boxes, which have their own warranties from their own manufacturers. Of the more than 830 modules on the list, 500 carry at least a five-year materials/workmanship warranty and about 250 are at 10 years.

A module’s power warranty guarantees that the module will produce a certain percent of its rated STC power (Pmp, minus any power tolerance) for a given period of time. A common warranty is 90% of rated power for up to 10 years and 80% for up to 25 years. Silicon Energy and MAGE Solar offer 30-year, 80% rated-power warranties—tops on the list. (Silicon Energy also offers a best-of-list 15-year, 90% rated-power warranty.) All of the modules that have 10-year materials warranties have at least 25-year, 80% rated-power warranties.

About 75 modules on the list have 25-year linear warranties, including modules from Scheuten Solar, SCHOTT Solar, Siliken, SolarWorld, Suntech, Tianwei New Energy, Trina Solar, and Upsolar. Compared to a percentage warranty (where a module at year 11 could only make 80% rated power and still meet the warranty), a 25-year, 80% linear warranty means the module output is warranted to not decrease more than 0.8% per year—at year 11, the most it could have decreased would be 8.8%.

A longer warranty implies better protection for the module owner. Of course, it is important to consider the company that is offering the warranty, especially with so many new companies in the market. Additionally, testing to verify power production and pursuing power warranty claims can be a difficult and time-consuming procedure.

Access

Brian Mehalic is a NABCEP-certified PV installer and ISPQ-certified PV instructor. He has experience designing and installing both PV and solar thermal systems, and is a curriculum developer and instructor for Solar Energy International.

Comments (2)

jenniferwoods's picture

I was actually searching for the most reliable one. Now as it is said about Sunpower, this must be considered seriously.

Jim and Elaine Stack's picture

check Sunpower panels before you get any. All are good and you can't go wrong but Sunpower are also twice as good as any I have seen. The local ASU TUV PTL labs test panels from all over the world. Sunpower really stands out above all others.

PS I don't sell or work for Sunpower, I just wish I did !

Show or Hide All Comments

Advertisement

X
You may login with either your assigned username or your e-mail address.
The password field is case sensitive.
Loading